The Supreme Court Refuses to Revisit Dewsnup
The Supreme Court won’t be overruling Dewnsup this year, and probably never. Yesterday, the justices denied the petition for certiorari in Ritter v. Brady, 18-747 (Sup. Ct.).
Dewsnup was the notorious 1992 decision where the Supreme Court held that a chapter 7 debtor may not employ Sections 506(a) and 506(d) to “strip down” an undersecured mortgage. Dewsnup v. Timm, 502 U.S. 410 (1992). Justice Antonin Scalia wrote a vigorous dissent, accusing the majority of ignoring the plain language of the statute in adopting a policy contrary to decisions that Congress made by enacting the Bankruptcy Code.
Twenty-three years later, the justices seemed primed to revisit Dewsnup. At oral argument in Bank of America N.A. v. Caulkett, 135 S. Ct. 1995 (2015), several justices apparently thought Dewsnup was wrongly decided. Indeed, the unanimous opinion in Caulkett, written by Justice Clarence Thomas, said that “straightforward reading of the statute” would allow a debtor to strip off an underwater mortgage.
The Dewsnup issue arose in Ritter, where the chapter 7 debtor sought to strip off a wholly underwater mortgage. All the way through the Ninth Circuit, the courts summarily denied the debtor’s request, saying the issue had been decided definitively by the Supreme Court in Caulkett.
Scott L. Nelson of the Public Citizen Litigation Group of Washington, D.C., along with Bradley Girard and Brian Wolfman of the Georgetown Law Appellate Court Immersion Clinic, filed a certiorari petition in December. Several law professors and former judges, including Eugene Wedoff, Leif M. Clark and Bruce A. Markell, filed amicus briefs urging the Court to grant certiorari.
Related Stories
April 30, 2020
Chapter 13 plans can be extended up to 7 years 7 year Chapter 13. An…
April 29, 2020
Loan modifications under CARES Act. The law firm assists with loan modifications and mortgage relief…
April 18, 2020
Small business owners qualify for chapter 7 bankruptcy. The Coronavirus aftermath is destroying small businesses….
April 18, 2020
Glossary of Credit Terms 2-percent rule A rule of thumb to see if refinancing a…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
April 17, 2020
STEPS IN A BANKRUPCY CASE Mandatory Credit Counseling You must obtain a certificate from an…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
April 15, 2020
Convert a Chapter 13 to a Chapter 7 A chapter 13 client (currently in a…
April 14, 2020
April 14, 2020
How to file a bankruptcy book. This book discusses the “nuts and bolts” of getting a…
April 30, 2020
Chapter 13 plans can be extended up to 7 years 7 year Chapter 13. An…
April 29, 2020
Loan modifications under CARES Act. The law firm assists with loan modifications and mortgage relief…
April 18, 2020
Small business owners qualify for chapter 7 bankruptcy. The Coronavirus aftermath is destroying small businesses….
April 18, 2020
Glossary of Credit Terms 2-percent rule A rule of thumb to see if refinancing a…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
April 17, 2020
STEPS IN A BANKRUPCY CASE Mandatory Credit Counseling You must obtain a certificate from an…
Posted in: Debt & Bankruptcy
April 15, 2020
Convert a Chapter 13 to a Chapter 7 A chapter 13 client (currently in a…
April 14, 2020
April 14, 2020
How to file a bankruptcy book. This book discusses the “nuts and bolts” of getting a…